ClickCease

24/7 Legal Help w/ Videoconferencing Available.

Call  (814) 480-0575

Search & Seizure

Can Police Lie About Having a Search Warrant? What to Do When Officers Are at Your Door

Sebald, Hackwelder & Knox•7 min read

Key Takeaways

  • Police can’t get around your rights by claiming a warrant they don’t have. If you let them in because they said they had one, that isn’t consent to the search.
  • Police don’t have to show you the warrant before they search, but they must leave you a copy of it and the affidavit when they’re done.
  • “We’ll get a warrant” is different from “we have a warrant.” You can still say no.
  • A real warrant has to be based on true facts. If police lied to a judge to get it, the warrant can be thrown out.
  • Don’t argue or block the door. Say clearly that you don’t consent, and let your lawyer challenge the search in court.

Can Police Say They Have a Warrant When They Don’t?

Our video on what to do when police show up to search your home drew more than 800 comments. One claim kept coming up: “Police are allowed to lie and say they have a valid warrant when they do not.” Attorney Eric Hackwelder’s answer was simple: “That is not true.”

Police do have some room to mislead you during questioning, as we explain in can police lie to you? Claiming legal authority they don’t have is a different matter. In Bumper v. North Carolina (1968), officers told a homeowner they had a warrant, and she let them in. The U.S. Supreme Court held that this wasn’t consent. When an officer says he has a warrant, he’s telling you that you have no right to refuse, and going along with that isn’t a free choice.

That means the search can’t later be justified by saying you agreed to it. If there was no warrant, or the warrant wasn’t valid, the evidence from the search can be challenged and suppressed.

Do Police Have to Show You the Warrant?

Not before they search. “Police don’t have to show you the warrant,” as Eric says at the start of the video. The U.S. Supreme Court confirmed in United States v. Grubbs (2006) that the Fourth Amendment doesn’t require officers to hand you the warrant before a search begins.

Pennsylvania does set rules for how a warrant is served:

  • Knock and announce. Before entering, officers must identify themselves and explain their authority and purpose, then wait a reasonable time for a response, unless an emergency requires immediate entry. If no one lets them in, they can force their way in (Pa.R.Crim.P. 207).
  • A copy when they’re done. Officers must leave a copy of the warrant and the supporting affidavit, plus a receipt for anything they take. They have to leave the copy even if they seize nothing, and if no one is home, they leave it in a conspicuous place (Pa.R.Crim.P. 208). The one exception is an affidavit a court has sealed.

You can always ask to see the warrant, and many officers will show it to you. If they won’t, that isn’t a reason to resist. It’s something to tell your lawyer.

“We Have a Warrant” vs. “We’ll Get a Warrant”

A more common line at the door is “If you don’t let us in, we’ll just get a warrant.” That isn’t a claim to already have one. Pennsylvania courts have held that this kind of statement doesn’t automatically make your consent involuntary. It’s one factor a court weighs in deciding whether you agreed freely (Commonwealth v. Mack, 2002).

You can still say no. If police have probable cause, they can apply to a judge for a warrant. If they don’t, they can’t get one. While they wait for a warrant, police with probable cause may keep you from going back inside alone for a reasonable time (Illinois v. McArthur, 2001). But saying no keeps the decision with a judge instead of with you on your front step.

What If It’s an Arrest Warrant?

When officers say they have “a warrant,” ask what kind. An arrest warrant is different from a search warrant. An arrest warrant lets police enter the named person’s own home to arrest them if they have reason to believe that person is inside. It doesn’t let them enter someone else’s home to look for that person without a search warrant, consent or an emergency (Steagald v. United States, 1981). And it doesn’t authorize a search of your house for evidence.

A Real Warrant Has to Be Based on the Truth

Even a warrant that exists can be invalid. As Eric explains, a valid search warrant and its affidavit of probable cause must contain true and accurate facts, “and if they did lie, then the warrant would be invalid.”

To get a warrant, an officer swears to an affidavit in front of a judge, and under Pa.R.Crim.P. 203 the judge can’t consider anything outside it. Under Franks v. Delaware (1978), if an officer included false information knowingly or with reckless disregard for the truth, and the warrant depended on it, the court sets the false statements aside. If what’s left doesn’t establish probable cause, the warrant is void and the evidence is excluded.

Pennsylvania is tougher on bad warrants than federal courts. In Commonwealth v. Edmunds (1991), the state Supreme Court held that Pennsylvania has no “good faith” exception. Evidence from a warrant that isn’t supported by probable cause is generally suppressed, even if the officers who carried out the search believed it was valid. A warrant can also fail for other reasons, such as stale information or a description that isn’t specific enough (Pa.R.Crim.P. 205).

What to Do When Police Say They Have a Warrant

  • Ask to see it. You can ask through a closed door or window. If officers knock without a warrant, you don’t have to open the door or talk to them (Kentucky v. King, 2011).
  • Don’t resist. If they say they have a warrant, don’t block the door or physically interfere, even if you think they’re lying.
  • Say you don’t consent. Say clearly, “I do not consent to any search.” If the warrant turns out not to exist or isn’t valid, the search can’t be justified by your consent.
  • Don’t answer questions. Tell officers you want to speak with a lawyer. Our guide on what to say to police explains how.
  • Keep the paperwork. Hold on to the copy of the warrant, the affidavit and the receipt. Write down what was searched, what was taken and the officers’ names.

How an Illegal Search Gets Challenged

The fight happens in court, not at your front door. Your lawyer reviews the warrant and affidavit, or the lack of one, and files a motion to suppress if something doesn’t hold up. If the search was illegal, the evidence can be thrown out, along with evidence police found because of it, often called “fruit of the poisonous tree” (Wong Sun v. United States).

Suppression doesn’t automatically end a case, but when the search produced the key evidence, it can change everything. If police searched your home, car or phone and something didn’t seem right, our criminal defense team can review what happened and tell you whether the search can be challenged.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can police lie about having a search warrant?

They can’t use that lie to get around your rights. Under Bumper v. North Carolina, letting officers in because they claimed a warrant isn’t consent. If no valid warrant existed, the search can be challenged and the evidence suppressed.

Do police have to show me the warrant before they search?

No. You can ask to see it, but they aren’t required to show it first. In Pennsylvania, they must leave a copy of the warrant and the supporting affidavit, along with a receipt for anything they take, unless a court has sealed the affidavit.

What if police say they’ll get a warrant if I don’t let them in?

You can still refuse. That statement isn’t a claim to already have a warrant. Police would need to show a judge probable cause to get one, and they may keep you from going back inside alone while they wait.

What happens if police lied to a judge to get the warrant?

Your lawyer can request a Franks hearing. If the court finds the officer knowingly or recklessly included false information, and the rest of the affidavit doesn’t establish probable cause, the warrant is thrown out and the evidence is suppressed.

Police searched your home? Something not seem right?

Our team can review the warrant, or the lack of one, and tell you whether the search can be challenged. We’re available 24/7.

Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This page is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.